Eclipse

Praise:
-fight scenes were AWESOME! (training in particular was waaayyy cool!)
-thumbs up for Jaspers southern accent
-loved Rosalie's creepy flashback
-Jacob kisses bella #1 and "I kissed Bella and she broke her hand on my face."
-Jacob kissed Bella #2(particularly the HILARIOUS look on Edwards face.)


Critique:
-the conversation between Edward and Jacob in the tent was NOT at all that civil.
-Where was the scene where Jacob ran away?(kind of important I thought)
-Why couldn't we have seen Carlisles past?(That was pretty awesome in the book)